Hi Kathy, I appreciate your question but if timelines and history count for nothing then there is no answer that can be given. I appreciate that many may have the perspective that Israel drove the Palestinians onto the tiny piece of land and then blockaded it, but I assure you that's not what happened. Of course, you're right that it was an unliveable situation and Israel's total withdrawal in 2005 was naive in that such a move was never going to actually lay a path to peace, instead leading to an overcrowded blockaded piece of land under terror rule.